Our menu is packed with handcrafted pizzas, hot subs, wings, salads, pasta, and more — all made fresh with the best ingredients. Whether you’re dining in, taking out, or ordering online, Goodfellas Pizza brings the flavor fast.
Cut fresh daily & garnished with lettuce & tomatoes
ITALIAN COMBO
Ham, Genoa salami, capicola, provolone, onions & Italian dressing
DOWNTOWN
Ham, roast beef, turkey, provolone, onions, oil & vinegar
WALL STREET
Turkey breast, provolone, onions, oil & vinegar
PARK AVENUE
Top round roast beef, provolone, onions, oil & vinegar
ALL AMERICAN
Ham, provolone & mayo
THE COVE
Made with solid white tuna
PHILLY CHEESE STEAK
With grilled onions
STEAK GANGSTER
Philly Deluxe with jalapeño peppers
STEAK BOMB
Philly cheese steak, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & mayo
STEAK, POTATOES & GRILLED ONIONS
On a soft roll with cheese & mayo
PIZZA STEAK
Pizza sauce, mozzarella & steak
CHICKEN PHILLY
With grilled onions & cheese
CHICKEN PHILLY CLASSIC
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions & mayo
CHICKEN CAESAR
Breaded chicken breast served with romaine, romano & Caesar dressing
BROOKLYN DIP
Top round rare roast beef with melted Swiss, our peppercom horseradish sauce & a side of au jus, (now made on the panini press)
BUFFALO CHICKEN
Bleu cheese, lettuce, tomatoes & onions
"SOUTH BEACH"
Chicken breast (grilled, fried or blackened), melted mozzarella, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, mayo & Italian dressing
BRONX BOMBER
Prosciutto, roasted peppers & tomatoes layered with fresh mozzarella, basil & virgin olive oil, panini pressed
EVERYTHING STROMBOLI
Sausage, pepperoni, ham, mushrooms, onions, peppers, black olives & cheese rolled in our fresh dough & baked to perfection, served with sauce
VEGGIE STROMBOLI
Eggplant, broccoli, spinach, mushrooms, peppers, onions, tomatoes, artichokes, black olives & cheese
STEAK STROMBOLI
Steak, onions, mushrooms, peppers & cheese rolled in our fresh dough
Fresh baked turnovers filled with Grande® ricotta, mozzarella & romano with your choice of additional fillings, served with a side of homemade sauce
-
Each Additional Filling
$2.50
Stuffed Rolls are all 8.95 & are served with sauce
GOOD FELLA'S ITALIAN DELI
NEW YORK-STYLE CHEESECAKE
HOMEMADE ZEPPOLI
Fried dough & powdered sugar
TOASTED ALMOND CREAM CAKE
DRINKS
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Sierra Mist, Mug Rootbeer, Mountain Dew, Dr Pepper, Lemonade, Iced Tea, Ginger Ale
2 Liters also available
BOTTLED WATER, GATORADE, MANHATTAN SPECIAL, SAN PELLEGRINO SPARKLING WATER OR PURE LEAF TEAS
CHEESE FRIES
Mozzarella & cheddar melted over fries
SIDE OF SAUSAGE OR MEATBALLS
FRIED MUSHROOMS
Fresh mushrooms fried in a garlic parmesan breading
MEZZALUNA
Crispy mozzarella triangles served with our delicious homemade marinara
PEPPERONI BITES
Served with a small sauce
SLICED ZUCCHINI
Served with buttermilk ranch
FRIED RAVIOLI
Ravioli covered in Italian bread crumbs, deep fried & served with marinara
CHICKEN FINGERS
Served with honey mustard or BBQ sauce
BUFFALO CHICKEN FINGERS
Tossed in our medium sauce
ITALIAN FEAST
Mozzarella Sticks, Chicken Fingers, Fried Mushrooms, Sliced Zucchini & Fried Ravioli served with 3 sauces
JUMBO WINGS OR BONELESS WINGS
Includes sauce, celery & bleu cheese dressing SAUCE: Medium Hot BBQ Garlic. Teriyaki Sweet & Sour Thai Chili Spice Honey Garlic. Honey BBQ Honey Mustard Gold Rush Lemon Pepper. Garlic Parm Mango Habanero Tropical Rum Blackened Dry Rub
SOUP OF THE DAY
Ask about today's selection
ITALIAN WEDDING
Chicken based soup with meatballs, spinach, pasta & vegetables
CHOOSE YOUR DRESSING: House Creamy Italian Bleu Cheese Thousand Island French Greek Ranch Honey Mustard Lemon Vinaigrette With Grilled, Blackened or Fried Chicken add 4.50 With Grilled or Blackened Shrimp add 5.95
TOSSED SALAD
Dinner salad with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumbers & homemade croutons
FRESH TUNA SALAD
Solid white tuna served on a bed of mixed greens, tomatoes & cucumbers
GREEK SALAD
Pepperoncini, feta, Kalamata olives, red onions, fresh tomatoes & cucumbers tossed with lettuce & drizzled with homemade Greek dressing
CHEF
Ham, turkey, cheese, cucumbers & egg over a bed of lettuce & tomatoes
ANTIPASTO
Lettuce with ham, salami, pepperoni, roasted peppers, black olives, pepperoncini, provolone & artichoke hearts, served with house dressing
FRESH MOZZARELLA ALLA CAPRESE
Fresh mozzarella & sliced tomatoes topped with fresh basil & roasted peppers drizzled in extra virgin olive oil
FRIED CHICKEN SALAD
Fried chicken strips, lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, house dressing cheddar & crumbled bacon
CAESAR SALAD
Fresh romaine lettuce, Caesar dressing, homemade croutons & romanoWith Grilled or Blackened Chicken
$4.50
With Grilled or Blackened Shrimp
$5.95
GOODFELLA'S SALAD
Lettuce, black olives, roasted red peppers, artichoke hearts, tomatoes, cucumbers & pepperonciniWith Grilled or Blackened Chicken
$4.50
With Grilled or Blackened Shrimp
$5.95
Please allow extra time for all gourmet pizzas
Served with your choice of spaghettini or penne, a fresh tossed salad & homemade garlic knots Substitute your salad for a soup add 2.95
Served with a fresh tossed salad & homemade garlic knots Substitute your salad for a soup add 2.95
Served with a fresh tossed salad & homemade garlic knots Substitute your salad for a soup add 2.95
