top of page

Born on the Coast. Built for Cravings.

GOODFELLAS 1ST DAY JUNE 250061.jpg

The Combo Everyone's Talking About

– Only $25.95

 Now Catering Corporate Events – Book Today!

SERVING ORIGINAL RECIPES SINCE 1996

Family-owned and serving Florida’s Treasure Coast since 1996, Goodfellas Pizza is known for handcrafted pizzas, hot wings, subs, fresh salads, and homemade pasta. With nine neighborhood locations from Jupiter to Sebastian, our commitment to quality and community shines through every slice. Whether you're dining in, picking up, catering, or ordering online—we’re here to feed families, fuel game nights, and celebrate everything in between.

Favorites That Never Miss

#22 5 GOUMET STUFFED ROLLS.jpg
#2 10 WINGS-GARLIC KNOTS COMBO.jpg
#32 SHRIMP SCAMPI.jpg
#22 ANTIPASTO SALAD.jpg

FRESH ANTIPASTO SALAD

0pc_96_OMO_GoodfellasPizza5_22_digital1920x1080_final.png

Coast-to-Coast Flavor – One Zip at a Time

Florida’s Favorite Slice

Serving up the Treasure Coast’s best pizza since 1996—with nine locations.

trim_edited.jpg

New specialty pies, online-only offers & secret menu drops are coming. 

Catering, Delivery, Loyalty — Soon To Be All In One Place.

IMG_2966_edited_edited_edited_edited.jpg

Party Trays & Catering

Feed a crowd with pasta, wings, and more. Perfect for events, offices, or family gatherings

#4 HALF SUB+ FRIES+F. DRINK.jpg

​Combo Meals 

Satisfy your hunger with our perfectly paired meals—featuring pizza slices, subs, wings, and fries. Great for lunch, dinner, or on-the-go cravings.

#5 two 16_ 1 toping + 20 WINGS.jpg

Family Favorites

Pies made daily with rotating ingredients. Check out what’s hot at your nearest location.

IMG_5998_edited.jpg

Be the First to Know When Our App Drops!

Sign up to get early access, app-only deals, and VIP alerts for our mobile ordering launch.

Launching soon on iOS + Android — Goodfellas in your pocket.

Randi Sperling

“Ordered pizza extra crispy and onion rings and the onion rings were the absolute best we've ever had. Had to force ourselves to stop eating them so we would have room for pizza! The pizza? Angels sang. The entire meal. Delivered so fast! Thank you!!."

Warren Vitale

Best pizza on the treasure coast.

Lynn Lorino

"Best pizza in town!! Excellent dinners also.Pasta dinners are delicious."
bottom of page